Tag: cognitive behavioral therapy

Realistic Goal Setting: Why Most New Year’s Resolutions Fail (and What Actually Works)

Posted on by David Zerella, LCSW in Uncategorized

Every January, many people set New Year’s resolutions with the hope that this will be the year they finally become more disciplined, motivated, organized, emotionally regulated, physically healthier, and financially stable.

By February, most of those goals have stalled or been abandoned.

This is not because people are lazy or lack willpower. More often, resolutions fail because goal-setting is approached from an unrealistic psychological framework.

Understanding why New Year’s resolutions fail—and how behavior change actually works—can help create more sustainable and mentally healthy goals.

The Motivation Myth in Goal Setting

One of the most common beliefs behind failed resolutions is:

“I need to be motivated to start.”

Although this belief feels intuitive, it is psychologically inaccurate. From a Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT) perspective, this represents an unrealistic expectation that often leads to avoidance, frustration, and self-criticism.

Motivation is not a prerequisite for action. In most cases, motivation follows behavior, not the other way around. Research in behavioral psychology consistently shows that action precedes emotional momentum.

Waiting to feel motivated before starting is similar to waiting for confidence before engaging in the behavior that builds confidence. The sequence is reversed.

Why Unrealistic Goals Lead to Burnout

In addition to relying on motivation, many people construct goals that are overly broad or rigid:

“I’m going to completely change my life.” “I’m never doing that again.” “I’m all in or nothing.”

These all-or-nothing approaches are common cognitive distortions. While they may feel decisive, they often lead to burnout and reinforce the belief that setbacks reflect personal failure.

Sustainable behavior change tends to be incremental, repetitive, and unremarkable.

One habit.

Made manageable.

Repeated imperfectly.

This is not a lack of ambition—it is a more accurate model of how long-term change occurs.

The Problem with “New Year, New Me”

Popular self-improvement narratives often suggest that meaningful change requires becoming a different person. Clinically, this framing can undermine self-efficacy by implying that the current self is insufficient to initiate growth.

From a therapeutic perspective, progress does not require reinvention. It requires consistent effort from the existing self.

Behavior change is not an identity overhaul. It is a practice.

How Self-Defeating Thoughts Sabotage Progress

Before people disengage behaviorally, they often disengage cognitively. Self-defeating beliefs typically precede avoidance.

Common examples include:

“I need to feel motivated to start.” “I should be further along by now.” “If I can’t do it perfectly, what’s the point?”

Although these thoughts may feel true, they tend to increase psychological pressure, reduce distress tolerance, and make quitting more likely.

A Rational Alternative to Motivation-Based Change

REBT emphasizes replacing unhelpful beliefs with rational, flexible alternatives that support persistence:

“I do not need to feel motivated to act.” “I can tolerate discomfort.” “I can improve one small thing at a time.” “Effort itself has value.”

This is not positive thinking or affirmation-based work. It is cognitive restructuring grounded in behavioral principles.

Progress is built through daily effort and consistency, especially when motivation is low.

Practical, Realistic Goal Setting Strategies

For individuals seeking healthier and more effective goal setting, the following principles are supported by behavioral psychology and clinical practice:

Focus on behaviors rather than outcomes Choose one habit instead of multiple simultaneous changes Expect discomfort and plan for it rather than avoiding it Measure success by follow-through, not intensity

Less pressure.

More discipline.

Smaller steps.

This approach does not lower standards—it places them where they are psychologically sustainable.

Keywords targeted: realistic goal setting, New Year’s resolutions and mental health, motivation and behavior change, REBT therapy, behavior change psychology, self-discipline vs motivation

Accountability as a Path to Growth

Posted on by David Zerella, LCSW in Uncategorized

Human psychology exists for the purpose of survival. Much of what we do—consciously or unconsciously—stems from the instinct to protect ourselves. This can often show up in unpleasant ways such as selfishness, defensiveness, or even narcissism. This is because we cling to our sense of self, avoid shame, and fight to maintain control. When someone holds us accountable, or offers constructive feedback, it feels like a direct threat. This feedback threatens our fragile survival system.

But what if feedback isn’t a threat at all? What if it’s the very thing that helps us move closer to who we want to be?

Reframing Criticism

Most of us have been conditioned to see accountability as punitive – a consequence for getting “caught” doing something wrong. That mindset might work comfortably when it’s holding others accountable, but when the focus shifts to us, it triggers defensiveness, denial, or blame-shifting.

At its core, though, constructive feedback can be a mirror. It reflects how our actions affect others, reveals our blind spots, and increases self-awareness. Instead of viewing criticism as an attack, we can see accountability as an invitation- an opportunity to self-actualize. When we move from fear to receptiveness, feedback stops feeling like a strike against our worth and becomes a compass guiding us in a better direction.

From “Fuck You” to “Thank You”

Imagine a culture where feedback isn’t met with hostility but with gratitude. Instead of a reflexive “fuck you” when we’re challenged, we respond with “thank you.”

Thank you for helping me see what I couldn’t.

Thank you for trusting me enough to call me to corrective action.

Thank you for letting me know where you stand so I can properly adapt.

That small shift can have profound effects. It builds trust in relationships, strengthens communities, and creates workplaces and families where honesty isn’t feared but welcomed. Accountability stops being a weapon and becomes a gift when we reframe it.

Choosing Growth Over Defense

This isn’t easy. Our instinct to protect ourselves won’t disappear overnight. But each time we catch ourselves getting defensive, we have a choice: double down on pride, or lean into growth. The latter requires humility, vulnerability, and courage. Yet it also leads to freedom—the freedom that comes from knowing we don’t have to be perfect, only willing to learn.

Unconditional self acceptance is the foundation of this work. Only when we accept ourselves fully can we acknowledge our mistakes and embrace feedback without shame.

If we, collectively, begin to approach accountability this way, we will change not just our individual lives but the culture we live in. A culture less obsessed with defending the ego and more committed to becoming better, together.

So the next time someone calls you out—or calls you in—pause. Breathe. And maybe, just maybe, try saying “thank you.” This week, let’s choose one phrase as our accountability anchor. Use something like “Thank you, I’ll have to think about that.” Carry it with you. Practice using it the next time feedback comes your way.

From “Have To” to “Get To”: Practicing Gratitude in the Everyday

Posted on by David Zerella, LCSW in Uncategorized

Gratitude is elusive. We know it’s available, but in the rush of daily life it can be difficult to recognize in the moment.

There’s value in what we might call grand gratitude—the ability to appreciate life as a whole. But that big-picture perspective can fade when we’re met with the sharp edges of stress, conflict, anxiety, or depression. In those moments, sweeping gratitude for “life itself” doesn’t always feel useful.

I often ask myself: I love my life, but do I love living it? Do I love every minute of it? Of course, it’s unreasonable to expect constant joy. But it raises a deeper question—how can I improve my relationship with gratitude?

One answer lies in reframing. Instead of telling myself I have to do something, I try to remind myself I get to. I get to do the things I don’t want to do. I get to live. I get to struggle. Each unwelcome task is still an opportunity—for growth, for strength, or for building resilience.

This shift feels especially relevant on Labor Day. We celebrate the chance to rest from work, but does that mean we can’t also celebrate the work itself? In America, our relationship with productivity is often demanding, even unhealthy. Work is tied to survival, status, and identity. Yet beyond making money, work can also serve as a source of purpose. What if we allowed ourselves to appreciate both sides—the days of rest and the days of labor?

The same applies to our inner lives. Just as we “get to” work for a paycheck, we also get to work on ourselves. We may not always want to, but the opportunity is there.

This is where mindfulness enters: it’s the practice of seeing opportunities where we might otherwise see burdens. To notice that we get to live, to get to struggle, to get to engage with the fullness of our human experience. Gratitude becomes less of a grand, abstract concept and more of an active, moment-to-moment practice.

The truth is, we don’t always have control over what life gives us. But we do have control over whether we see it as a burden—or as a gift we get to carry.

If you’d like to strengthen this practice, start small this week:

  • Pick one task you usually dread. Before you begin, pause and reframe it from “I have to” into “I get to.”
  • Notice what shifts. Even if the task doesn’t become enjoyable, see if it feels lighter, more purposeful, or more connected to growth.
  • Build from there. Over time, these small reframes can accumulate into a deeper sense of everyday gratitude.

This is the kind of mindful reframing I often explore with clients—finding practical ways to cultivate resilience, reduce stress, and stay connected to purpose. If you’re interested in working on your own practice of gratitude and perspective, I’d love to connect. Together, we can turn the “have to’s” of your life into meaningful “get to’s.”

✨ Want more reflections like this? Subscribe to my blog for biweekly insights on growth, healing, and mental health.

Until next time,

David Zerella, LCSW